Puerto Rico Weighs Nuclear Energy as Costs Rise and Grid Struggles Continue
M.A. Dworkin
San Juan, PR - Puerto Rico’s electricity debate has become impossible to separate from daily life. Bills remain a burden for many households and businesses, outages still disrupt routines, and the island’s energy system faces pressure from old infrastructure, imported fuels, storms, and a long transition toward cleaner power.
That is the backdrop for Governor Jenniffer González-Colón’s recent evaluation of nuclear energy as one possible piece of Puerto Rico’s future energy mix. The conversation has drawn attention because it connects several sensitive issues at once: affordability, reliability, safety, climate goals, and local control over energy decisions.
The governor’s visit to the former BONUS reactor site in Rincón, alongside Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commissioner David A. Wright and University of Puerto Rico students, did not signal a final decision. It did signal something more modest but still important: Puerto Rico is reopening a serious policy discussion about whether advanced nuclear technologies, especially small modular reactors, could fit into the island’s long-term clean-energy plans.

Why Puerto Rico is looking at new energy options
Electricity in Puerto Rico is often expensive, and the reasons are layered. The island has long depended heavily on imported fossil fuels for power generation. That creates exposure to global fuel price swings, shipping costs, and supply risks. When fuel costs rise, customers often feel it in their monthly bills.
Reliability is the other major problem. Puerto Rico’s grid has faced years of strain from aging equipment, deferred maintenance, financial challenges, storms, earthquakes, and the long recovery from Hurricane Maria. Even when generation is available, transmission and distribution problems can still leave communities in the dark.
Energy planning on an island is also different from energy planning on a mainland grid. Puerto Rico cannot easily draw power from neighboring states during a shortage. It does not have a large regional grid to lean on. That means the island needs a power system that can balance several goals at once:
Lower and more stable costs for homes, schools, hospitals, and businesses
More reliable service during normal demand and emergencies
Less dependence on imported fuels
Progress toward clean-energy targets
Energy sources that can survive severe weather and other disruptions
Solar power, batteries, energy efficiency, wind, and grid repairs all play major roles in that discussion. Nuclear energy is now being discussed as another possible option, not as a replacement for everything else, but as a potential source of steady, low-carbon electricity.
That distinction matters. Puerto Rico is not choosing between one technology and all others. It is trying to answer a harder question: what mix of resources can provide clean, affordable, dependable power on an island with real limits and real risks?
What the BONUS reactor tour represents
The BONUS reactor, short for Boiling Nuclear Superheater, is an important site in Puerto Rico’s energy history. Located in Rincón, it was an early nuclear demonstration project and has not operated for decades. It is not a candidate for a simple restart, and current discussions should not be confused with turning an old plant back on.
The recent tour brought together Governor González-Colón, NRC Commissioner David A. Wright, and students from the University of Puerto Rico. That mix of participants is meaningful.
The NRC, or Nuclear Regulatory Commission, oversees civilian nuclear safety in the United States and its territories. Any serious nuclear proposal in Puerto Rico would face federal review, licensing standards, environmental analysis, emergency planning requirements, security rules, and public scrutiny. A visit from an NRC commissioner does not equal approval for a project. It does show that if Puerto Rico studies nuclear energy, safety regulation will be central from the start.
The presence of UPR students also matters. Energy choices made now will shape the careers and lives of the next generation of engineers, planners, scientists, economists, and community leaders. Puerto Rico would need its own technical workforce if it ever moved toward nuclear energy, even on a small scale. That includes expertise in grid planning, radiation protection, emergency management, construction, operations, inspection, and waste handling.
The tour also had symbolic value. The BONUS site is a reminder that nuclear energy is not a brand-new topic for Puerto Rico. The island has already hosted a nuclear facility, though in a very different era of technology and regulation. Revisiting that history can help ground the current debate in facts rather than fear or hype.
Still, symbolism has limits. The former BONUS reactor should be viewed as an educational and historical site in this discussion, not as a shortcut to future nuclear power.
The key message is simple: Puerto Rico is evaluating nuclear energy, not approving a nuclear plant.
House Bill 1092 changes the policy conversation
House Bill 1092 adds another layer to the discussion. The measure updates Puerto Rico’s public energy policy and removes barriers that had limited consideration of nuclear energy. In practical terms, it opens the door for nuclear technology to be studied as part of future planning.
That does not mean nuclear power is now guaranteed. It means policymakers have created room for analysis.
For years, public energy policy in many places treated nuclear energy as either politically off-limits or too complex to consider. Removing barriers does not settle the safety, cost, waste, schedule, or siting questions. It simply allows agencies, utilities, universities, and regulators to examine whether the technology could meet Puerto Rico’s needs.
That distinction is especially important because energy policy can shape investment long before a project exists. If a technology is excluded by law or policy, it cannot compete in planning models, feasibility studies, funding discussions, or workforce programs. If it is allowed for study, it must still prove itself.
House Bill 1092 may lead to questions such as:
Could advanced nuclear power help reduce dependence on imported fuels?
Would nuclear power lower or stabilize long-term electricity costs?
How would it interact with solar, wind, batteries, and demand response?
Where could a facility safely be located, if at all?
What would emergency planning look like on an island?
How would spent fuel be stored and secured?
Who would pay for development, construction, operations, insurance, and decommissioning?
How would the public be involved in each step?
These are not small questions. They require time, technical review, and trust. They also require transparency, because energy decisions in Puerto Rico carry a history of public frustration over costs, outages, contracts, and recovery delays.
A serious nuclear study would need to be open enough for people to see the assumptions, not just the conclusions.
Why small modular reactors are getting attention
The most likely nuclear technology to be discussed for Puerto Rico is not a large traditional nuclear plant. The focus is more likely to fall on small modular reactors, often called SMRs.
SMRs are designed to produce less electricity per unit than large nuclear reactors. Their backers say they could be built in factory-like settings, installed in stages, and used in places where a full-scale nuclear plant would be too large for the grid. Some designs aim to improve passive safety features, reduce operating complexity, or pair with industrial facilities and microgrids.
For Puerto Rico, the appeal is understandable. The island needs dependable power that can complement renewable energy. Solar generation is strongest during daylight hours. Batteries can store power, but large amounts of storage are costly and must be planned carefully. Wind can help, but output varies. A firm low-carbon power source could, in theory, help fill gaps when the sun is down, demand is high, or storms disrupt the system.
Puerto Rico has also set a clean-energy target for 2050. Reaching that target will require more than installing panels and hoping the grid catches up. It will require a system that can handle variable generation, protect critical services, and keep electricity affordable.
SMRs could be studied through that lens. They may offer:
Low-carbon generation Nuclear plants do not release carbon dioxide during power generation.
Steady output Nuclear power can operate around the clock, which can support grid stability.
Smaller scale than traditional reactors A smaller unit may fit an island grid better than a large conventional plant.
Potential use near critical loads In theory, smaller plants could support key infrastructure, though siting would be a major challenge.
Yet the word “potential” carries a lot of weight. Many SMR designs are still moving through licensing, demonstration, or early deployment stages. Costs remain uncertain. Construction timelines can change. Financing can be difficult. Public acceptance cannot be assumed.
Puerto Rico would also face island-specific concerns. Nuclear projects need strong emergency planning, secure sites, reliable cooling or heat-management systems based on design, skilled operators, and long-term waste management. Storm risk, seismic risk, coastal exposure, transportation routes, and community consent would all need careful review.
That does not make SMRs impossible. It does mean they cannot be treated as a quick fix.

The debate is still at an early stage
The most important clarification is also the easiest to miss: Puerto Rico has no formal plan to build new nuclear plants, and there is no formal plan to restart the BONUS reactor.
Current activity appears to be exploratory. The governor’s evaluation, the BONUS site tour, and the policy changes tied to House Bill 1092 all point to a preliminary phase. This is the stage where governments ask whether a technology deserves further study, not where they approve construction.
That matters for public trust. Nuclear energy often triggers strong reactions. Supporters may see it as a clean, reliable answer to high energy costs and fragile grids. Critics may worry about safety, waste, earthquakes, storms, cost overruns, and the risk of distracting from renewable energy and grid repairs.
Both sides raise real issues. A useful debate should avoid two unhelpful extremes. One extreme treats nuclear energy as a miracle solution that can solve Puerto Rico’s power problems by itself. The other treats any discussion of nuclear energy as reckless before the facts are examined.
Puerto Rico needs a better standard than slogans. A credible review would compare nuclear options against other paths using the same hard questions:
What does it cost over the full life of the project?
How long would it take to deliver power?
What risks does it reduce?
What risks does it create?
How would it affect monthly bills?
How would it perform during storms or grid failures?
Who regulates it?
Who is accountable if costs rise or schedules slip?
How will communities be consulted?
These questions should also apply to fossil fuels, renewables, batteries, transmission upgrades, and any other major energy investment. That is the only way to build an energy plan that is both ambitious and realistic.
Nuclear energy would be one part of a larger energy puzzle
Puerto Rico’s energy challenge is not only about generation. Building more power plants, of any kind, will not fix weak lines, damaged substations, slow repairs, or poor coordination. The island needs a stronger grid as much as it needs cleaner sources of electricity.
That is why the nuclear discussion should sit inside a wider plan. A durable strategy would likely include:
Faster deployment of rooftop and community solar where it makes sense
More battery storage for homes, businesses, and critical facilities
Hardening of transmission and distribution systems
Better vegetation management and maintenance
Clearer emergency plans for hospitals, water systems, and communications
Programs that reduce energy waste in buildings
Fair cost controls and transparent contracting
Workforce training through local universities and technical programs
If SMRs ever become a serious proposal, they would need to prove they strengthen that wider plan. They would also need to compete with other investments that may be faster, cheaper, or more familiar.
At the same time, ruling out options too early can carry its own cost. Puerto Rico’s clean-energy target for 2050 is demanding. The island must retire or reduce fossil generation, improve reliability, and keep rates manageable. That is a difficult balance. Studying firm low-carbon technologies, including nuclear energy, may be reasonable if the process is transparent and grounded in evidence.
The next phase should be careful, public, and practical. Puerto Rico does not need a rushed decision. It needs a clear evaluation of what nuclear energy can and cannot do for an island grid under stress.
The BONUS tour and House Bill 1092 have opened the door to that conversation. They have not answered the biggest questions. For now, the best reading is sober rather than dramatic: Puerto Rico is exploring nuclear energy because its current electricity problems are serious, its future clean-energy goals are ambitious, and every option on the table must earn public confidence.



